Ready to explore the world of sex toys but not sure where to begin? You’re not alone! Whether you’re shopping solo or with a partner, the first step can feel a bit overwhelming—but it should be fun, empowering, and totally judgment-free. Let’s break down what you need to know so your first experience is as pleasurable as it is stress-free.
Why Try Sex Toys?
Sex toys aren’t just about adding excitement—they’re about self-discovery, pleasure, and embracing your body’s unique needs. They can help you learn what feels good, boost confidence, and even strengthen relationships. Plus, who doesn’t love a little extra fun in the bedroom (or wherever inspiration strikes)?
What to Look For in Your First Sex Toy
1. Body-Safe Materials: Always choose toys made from non-porous, body-safe materials like medical-grade silicone, ABS plastic, or glass. Avoid anything with phthalates or jelly rubber.
2. Simplicity: Look for toys with easy-to-use controls and straightforward designs. There’s no need to start with bells and whistles—unless you want to!
3. Size Matters: Go for smaller, less intimidating shapes. Think bullet vibrators, slim wands, or compact suction toys.
4. Quiet Operation: If privacy is a concern, check the noise level. Many beginner toys are whisper-quiet.
5. Waterproof Options: Waterproof toys are great for bath or shower play and are easier to clean.
How to Start: Tips for First-Timers
- Do Your Research: Read reviews, ask questions, and don’t be afraid to reach out to staff at inclusive, education-focused stores (like Fantasy Gifts NJ!).
- Start Slow: Begin with external stimulation, like a bullet vibrator or a clitoral stimulator, before exploring internal toys.
- Use Lube: Lubricant is your best friend, especially for beginners. Water-based lube is safe with most materials.
- Set the Mood: Create a comfortable, private space. Light a candle, play your favorite playlist, and relax.
- Go at Your Own Pace: There’s no right or wrong way to explore. Listen to your body and don’t rush.
Top Picks: Beginner-Friendly Sex Toys

Bullet Vibes
Bullet vibes are a great place to start! They range from the simple, cheapy bullets like the Cal Exotic Silver bullet to the ultra powerful Sensuelle 60SX amp and every price point and power range in between!

Couple’s Rings
Vibrating rings add buzz for both partners. If you’ve never tried one before they’re great because they will do two things: first the cock ring will constrict the blood flow to the penis resulting in a longer, harder erection and second, the vibration will add external stimulation to the clitoral or perineum area – it’s a win/win! You can also start very small with a disposable ring like the Screaming O Vibrating Couple’s Cock Ring or splurge on something more powerful like the 10 function, waterproof, rechargeable, silicone VeDO Sexy Bunny Ring!

Clitoral Stimulators
Clitoral stimulators are designed for just one thing! And that makes them great at it! Did you know the clitoris has over 10000 nerve endings! Imagine just focusing all the attention and power on that one little nub!? Whether you’re using air pulse, a bullet, or a grinder, a clitoral stimulator will take your orgasm to the next level!

Slim G-Spot Vibrators
If you haven’t found your g-spot yet, you’re not lost, you just made need some help guiding you! A G-spot vibrator has a curved end that allows you to hit just the right spot. Not sure where to start? Our G-Spot Delight Bundle contains a g-spot vibrator, serum and lubricant to make your exploration easy and fun!

Anal Plugs (For the Curious)
If you’re interested in anal play, start with a small, silicone or metal plug. Look for flared bases and flexible stems—safety first! You can them explore larger plugs, plugs with jeweled decor, or vibrating plugs.
Common Questions from Beginners
Is it normal to feel nervous? Absolutely! The key is to approach your experience with curiosity and kindness toward yourself.
How do I clean my toys? Use warm water and mild, unscented soap, or a toy cleaner. Always dry thoroughly and store in a clean pouch.
Can I use sex toys with a partner? Definitely! Many couples find toys add excitement and intimacy. Communicate openly and pick something you’re both curious about.
What if I don’t like my first toy? That’s totally okay. Exploring is part of the fun, and preferences can change over time. Don’t be discouraged—there’s something for everyone!
Final Thoughts: Embrace the Journey
Your first sex toy should be all about discovery, pleasure, and empowerment. Don’t stress about “doing it right”—there is no right or wrong, only what feels good to you. And remember, the Fantasy Gifts NJ team is always here to answer questions and help you find your perfect match. Happy exploring!
Ready to start your journey? Visit us in-store or online for discreet, friendly advice and a curated selection of the best beginner toys.
Shop Fantasy Gifts NJ—Online or In-Store Explore your fantasies in Marlton, Turnersville, or Lumberton with staff who make shopping sexy, safe, and judgment-free. Prefer shopping online? FantasyGiftsNJ.com ships discreetly in plain packaging, with free shipping on orders over $69. Your little secret stays yours, but the adventure starts the moment you hit checkout.
Marlton: 735 W Route 70, Marlton, NJ 08053 | 856-596-0676Turnersville: 5101 Black Horse Pike, Turnersville, NJ 08012 | 856-228-7002Lumberton: 1603 NJ-38, Lumberton, NJ 08048 | 609-491-7521
About Fantasy Gifts
Fantasy Gifts New Jersey has spent more than thirty years helping South Jersey discover the sex toys they love and the better orgasms they absolutely deserve.
Our friendly, sex-positive, highly educated staff makes exploring pleasure feel easy, safe, and judgment-free. Step into our clean, comfortable stores and let us guide you toward the toys, tools, and sexual wellness essentials that spark your joy. If it promises more pleasure, you will find it on our shelves!
Visit any of our three locations in Turnersville, Marlton, or Lumberton, New Jersey.
You’ve got the top picks and all the insider tips. Now it’s time to bring the fun home. Shop the luxury toys from this list or EXPLORE OUR FULL COLLECTION to find the perfect way to heat things up together.